Credit: Shirley Wu; Source: “Elitism in Mathematics and Inequality,” by Ho-Chun Herbert Chang and Feng Fu, in Humanities and Social Sciences Communications; January 2021 (data)
Fields Medals Are Concentrated in Mathematical ‘Families’
Elite mathematicians tend to pass their prestige down to advisees
Clara Moskowitzis Scientific American's senior editor covering space and physics. She has a bachelor's degree in astronomy and physics from Wesleyan University and a graduate degree in science journalism from the University of California, Santa Cruz. Follow Moskowitz on Twitter @ClaraMoskowitz Credit: Nick Higgins
Shirley Wu is an award-winning creative focused on data-driven art and visualizations. She combines her love of art, math and code into colorful, compelling narratives that push the boundaries of the Web. Her work can be found at https://shirleywu.studio. Follow Shirley Wu on Twitter
In mathematics, as in many fields, who you know matters. An analysis of mathematicians' “ancestors” (their graduate school advisers) as well as their descendants (the students they advised) shows that elite researchers tend to produce elites. Mathematicians Feng Fu of Dartmouth College and Ho-Chun Herbert Chang of the University of Southern California analyzed connections among 240,000 mathematicians and found that winners of math's highest honor, the Fields Medal, were concentrated among just a few mathematical families. “If you want to win a Fields Medal, you want to study with a Fields Medalist,” Fu says.
Fu and Chang also tracked mathematicians' ethnicities* and found that “elite” researchers—defined as Fields Medalists and those closely connected to them—are usually American or European, despite the fact that mathematicians around the globe have made significant discoveries. Moreover, elites tend to have advisers and advisees that are also more American and European than the general population of mathematicians. “This is urging elite institutions to think carefully about how they can help elevate underrepresented mathematicians,” Chang says.
This article was originally published with the title "Mathematical Privilege" in Scientific American 325, 1, 80 (July 2021)